She writes about indian traditions, lost identities, importance of language, cultural difference to create different moods and themes. The poem a different history was written by sujata bhatt, and is about how the. Apr 02, 20 3 thoughts on a different history by sujata bhatt imogen april 12, 20 at 1. I spent most of my childhood in pune, studying in loyola and st. Sujata bhatt different history summary essay example. She has written the poem a different history which is used around many other schools for english gcse courseworks. Many of her poems have themes of violence and love. While the original shortened rendition of bhatta was bhat or bhatt, many of the migrants to the punjab region started spelling their surname as but or butt which is the spelling of the clan used in the pahari language. In the first stanza the repetition of the word book is used to show the importance of them, as books contain writing that provides information, ideas and can. This is psychological warfare and the most preferred action is communication. I was born in delhi, on nov 27,1967, the first child of prem narain bhatt and nirja bhatt nee uniyal.
May 22, 2016 brief context a different history explores the relationship between cultural identity and language. The history of the book has its roots in bibliography, librarianship, and the intersections of social, cultural, and material history. A different history analysis a different history is written by sujata bhatt. Sujata bhatt a different history in search for my tongue, another. Feb, 2012 sujata bhatt a different history in search for my tongue, another poem by sujata bhatt, she talks of the strangeness and difficulty of having two languages, and the fear of losing her mother tongue, the language she was brought up to speak by her mother. Religion and education in the poem a different history.
As you read the poem further you realize that she is talking about learning a new language. Using language as strain of culture and a representative of the people, she asks the reader to understand and identify with the fact that people across the globe at some time or the other have been. Poem analysis for different history by sujata bhatt, sample. A different history by sujata bhatt english with mr boucher. In the poem a different history, the poet sujata bhatt conveys the theme of the loss of culture and language through the use of repetition, rhetorical questions and symbols. Analysis on a different history by sujata bhatt answers. Part 1 sujata bhatt reflects and explores on the ideas of culture, values, human struggle, religion combined with its beliefs and acquisition of foreign or strange language. The poem is a commentary on the relationship between cultural. Analysis of a different history by sujata bhatt igcse. Proper nonfiction history books, not historical fiction, about any period, event, area or topic you like. She has emphasized in her poem by repeating words and questions and thereby making her poem stronger. She talks about how todays history is different for everyone.
Brief context a different history explores the relationship between cultural identity and language. The first enjambment talks about the book, which represents the culture and the way people should treat the books. Here, she also suggests the importance of language, especially the mother tongue. Narratives of expatriate life in the arab world is indeed threaded with various literary genres like travelogue physical as well as psychological, anecdotes and narration of daily. A different history by sujata bhatt analysis essay bartleby. Sujata bhatt a different history in search for my tongue, another poem by sujata bhatt, she talks of the strangeness and difficulty of having two languages, and the fear of losing her mother tongue, the language she was brought up to speak by her mother. Sujata bhatta different historynotes english language and. Jul 17, 20 explore the ideas in the poem a different history by sujata bhatt. With repeating the phrase, bhatt manages to reinforce the negative commentary and intensifies the critical tone of the poem with each sin described.
You should be gentle when turning the pages of the book that you read for knowledge of religion. Sujata bhatt different history summary essay on essay examples. The poem is divided up into two sections and the tone also changes from the descriptive to some very big questions. There is a reverence for language, books and the indian culture they represented. Her poem a different history dealing with the issues of globalization and westernization, featured in the poetry anthology used for igcse english examinations, for examination in 2014. A standout film from his earlier period is saaransh 1984, screened at the 14th moscow international film festival. In transit at dubai international prashant bhatt published on. What the author tries to do to persuade us during the poem is making us keep reading by expressing her feelings, her experiences and try to express them in a persuasive way. He traces the history of the psychological warfare to establish how steadily its importance has grown. She presides over all the fine arts and in india she is frequently worshipped in libraries.
The first part of poem reflects bhatts cultural background. She admits that, in spite of having to learn 4 languages she had to adapt herself to the english language. In a different history, bhatt focuses on indias rich. Books, of course, hold history, and she is basically saying that we should respect our history. A different history essay the poem a different history is a wonderful poem written by sujata bhatt. When bhatt discusses india in stanza one youll notice that the lines seem to float around beginning at different places. It is a sin to shove a book aside with your foot, a sin to slam books down hard on a table, a. A different history by sujata bhatt manusenglishportfolio. Note that although the degree of indentation is different, the border is the same. Born in india in 1956, her mother tonguegujerati, she has studied in britain andthe usa at the famed iowa writersworkshop, taught in canada, travelledwidely, and now lives and works ingermany. History can also mean the period of time after writing was invented.
Sujata bhatt different history summary the poetess strata bath, while writing this poem has given importance to the culture and various religions in india. A different history is about language as well as history. Bhatt details a genealogy of hinudtva that builds on its initial belief in a primordial hindu lineage by accumulating new concerns over time, such as antiminorityism. The poetess sujata bhatt, while writing this poem has given importance to the culture and various religions in india. There are 2 seperated parts in the story where there is 2 different themes and different. May 11, 2012 rick v a different history sujata bhatts poem a different history is an appealing poem because it its full of culture of a different country.
A different history sujata bhatt a different history. The real story of the great uprising is an even more interesting perspective because it is a true first person account by a humble konkan brahmin vishnu bhatt godshe versaikar who unfortunately chose the exact same time to seek to improve his families fortunes by travelling northwards to perform brahminical duties at kingdoms governed. She is, the new statesman declared, one of the finest poets alive. Prashant bhatts book or rather booklet entitled in transit at dubai international. It became indias official entry for the academy award for best foreign language film for that year. This poem is about the british colonization in india and importance of religions and culture in india. Sujata bhatt s multicultural perspectives on language, culture, art and history surely originate in her own life experiences. The most bhatt families were found in the uk in 1891. In one sense it represents the freedom of the gods, but on the other hand it could show the disorganisation of indian priorities gods and nature above the. Bhatt was born in india in 1956, studied in the united kingdom and united states, and lives now in germany. A different history a different history in this poem i mention the hindu goddess, sarasvati she is the goddess of knowledge. Although the second is not explicitly stated, the word conqueror and that strange language implying that the language is a different one from that originally spoken are two very obvious hints pointing that way. Summary of a different history by sujata bhatt ba english notes. Summary of a different history by sujata bhatt in this twostanza poem, sujata bhatt looks at the complex relationship between history language culture and identity.
Sujata bhatt different history summary essay pages. Sujata bhatt search for my tongue aqa anthology cluster 2. You should treat your books as the goddess of knowledge. Her poem is about the effects of globalization and colonization.
The poem is divided up into two sections and the tone also changes from the descriptive to ask some very big questions. It has emerged in recent decades as an academic discipline with its own undergraduate and postgraduate university courses, scholarly journals, monographic series, conferences, and research centers. It is methodologically diverse and interdisciplinary, situated. A different history poem essay free summaries examples. Analysis of a different history by sujata bhatt essay 860 words. A different history written by sujata bhatt portrays the loss of language and. What is the central idea of the poem a different history by sujata bhatt. Just wellwritten, wellresearched, informative and interesting books for historians, history students and history enthusiasts. Mahesh bhatt born 20 september 1948 is an indian film director, producer and screenwriter known for his works exclusively in hindi cinema. Historians state the surname is a distorted form of bhatta, which originates from sanskrit, meaning scholar according to the brahma. The central idea is that dont sin against books or godcreated things. Analysis of a different history by sujata bhatt essay. This was about 33% of all the recorded bhatts in the usa. Sujata bhatt a different history english literature essay uk essays.
In a different history by sujata bhatt, the author talks about india the author talks about indian culture and colonisation. The poet emigrated from india to the states when she was twelve. Scholars who write about history are called historians. Esl activity a different history by sujata bhatt english. Analysis of a different history sujata bhatt this is a line by line analysis of the poem. The sins include actions such as to shove a book aside with your foot, to slam books down hard on a table, a sin to toss one carelessly across 0a room. Oct 06, 2019 in this video, im gonna tell you a different history poem written by sujatha bhatt. Analysis of a different history by sujata bhatt essay example. A different history in this poem i mention the hindu goddess, sarasvati she is the goddess of knowledge. Sujata bhatts multicultural perspectiveson language, culture, art and historysurely originate in her own lifeexperiences. She has referred to god and books to talk about indian culture.
I didnt mean this to be a list of pop history, but i think its too late now, so you might as well go ahead. How does sujata bhatt strikingly illustrate the paradox of history in. Critic on a different history of sujata bhatt answers. In this twostanza poem, sujata bhatt looks at the complex relationship between history language culture and identity. Perhaps what is also meant by featuring a list of sins is to empahsise the wrong in mistreating books, to the extent of religious injustice which could evoke emotion and thought into anyone within the large and dominating christian religion which. Chetan bhatts hindu nationalism is a careful and excellent reconstruction of the ideas and ideology of hindutva in the century and a half of its existence. Arunkumar bhatt, who being a defense journalist knows nuances of communication and unfolds here this softkill strategy and its tactics. Analysis of a different history by sujata bhatt 1920 in this second stanza sujata bhatt addresses a number of key issues through rhetoric. In 1920 there was 1 bhatt family living in massachusetts. Firstly, is a brief overview of the poem and its author. The images range from greek and hindu gods snake monkeys trees and. This was about 33% of all the recorded bhatt s in the usa.
Bhatt invites the readers and takes them through the. A different history by sujata bhatt english with mr. A different history by sujata bhatt wednesday november 09th 2011, 9. The first of freedom and respect the second of rigidity and violence. Sujata bhatt reflects and explores on the ideas of culture, values, human struggle, religion combined with its beliefs and acquisition of foreign or strange language. It is a sin to shove a book aside with your foot, a sin to slam books down hard on a table, a sin to toss one carelessly across a room. It is a sin to shove a book aside with your foot, a sin to slam books down. This helps the reader to understand the meaning of the poem because it focuses on the metaphor of the books and encourages the. The poet obviously treats poetry as an art so it would be normal for her to be mentioned. Bhatt has been recognized as a distinctive voice in contemporary poetry. Explore the ideas in the poem a different history by sujata bhatt. Born in india, with gujarati as her mother tongue, she has studied in britain and the usa at the famed iowa writers workshop, taught in canada, travelled widely, and now lives and works in germany. Apr 30, 2014 analysis of a different history sujata bhatt this is a line by line analysis of the poem.
A different history by sujata bhatt analysis essay. The first enjambment talks about the book, which represents the culture and the. Sujata bhatta different historynotes english language. The bhat surname is associated with the brahmin varna of hinduism, however, large number of muslims retained the surname after their conversion to islam.
Sujata bhatt a different history english literature essay. Mar 10, 20 a different history by sujata bhatt poetry revision duration. Different in terms of our culture, influences, perceptions and all and how they all together have changed how we view history and how we act upon it. Massachusetts and 2 other states had the highest population of bhatt families in 1920. The bhatt family name was found in the usa, and the uk between 1891 and 1920. This helps the reader to understand the meaning of the poem because it focuses on the metaphor of the books and encourages the reader to think about how heshe treats nature. In this video, im gonna tell you a different history poem written by sujatha bhatt. A different history this poem is written by sujata bhatt who emigrated from india. Poem analysis for different history by sujata bhatt. It is a sin to shove a book aside with your foot, a sin to slam books. Analysis of a different history, by sujata bhatt the poetess sujata bhatt, while writing this poem has given importance to the culture and various religions in india. The poem a different history is steeped in the language of religious nature and oppression with the two stanzas offering contrasting visions. Bhatt explores the idea of history, culture and language throughout the poem.
205 1292 7 927 508 1140 1028 1479 1052 1130 771 361 564 1487 963 100 1197 1013 395 1307 676 129 191 1109 672 938 394 611 91 470 336 1188 90 1480 1145